Lesson 2 · 9 min
Elements between two people
Both traditions sort their signs into elements and read meaning in how two people's elements meet. This lesson compares the four Western elements with the five Chinese phases and their cycles.
Four Western elements
Western astrology groups the twelve signs into four elements. Fire is Aries, Leo and Sagittarius. Earth is Taurus, Virgo and Capricorn. Air is Gemini, Libra and Aquarius. Water is Cancer, Scorpio and Pisces. Astrologers read fire as warmth and drive, earth as steadiness, air as ideas and talk, and water as feeling.
When two people share an element, their placements fall in signs that are four apart around the zodiac, which is the trine relationship you will meet in the next lesson. Astrologers read this as easy understanding, sometimes so easy that it lacks challenge.
Traditionally fire pairs well with air, and earth pairs well with water. Air feeds fire, the saying goes, and water nourishes earth. Fire with water, or air with earth, is read as a meeting of different temperaments that may need more translation.
Five Chinese phases
Chinese tradition uses five phases, called wuxing: Wood, Fire, Earth, Metal and Water. The word phase fits better than element, because these are stages of change rather than fixed substances. Every heavenly stem and earthly branch belongs to one phase.
In BaZi, the Four Pillars system, the most personal phase is the Day Master. The Day Master is the heavenly stem of the day pillar, and the tradition reads it as the self. When two charts are compared, astrologers often begin by asking how the two Day Masters meet.
The phases are not only in the Day Master. Each pillar has a stem and a branch, and each carries a phase, so a full chart holds eight. In compatibility work, astrologers sometimes also ask whether one person's chart supplies a phase the other's chart lacks, an idea of balance that sits alongside the simple Day Master comparison.
The generating cycle
In the generating cycle each phase feeds the next: Wood feeds Fire, Fire makes Earth (as ash), Earth bears Metal, Metal carries Water (as condensation, in one traditional image), and Water nourishes Wood. Then the circle begins again.
Between two people, a generating link is read as support. If one Day Master is Water and the other Wood, the Water person is read as nourishing the Wood person. The reading has a direction: one side gives, the other receives. Astrologers note that this can feel warm, or, if one person always gives, tiring.
Direction matters in the reading. Water to Wood is not the same as Wood to Water. When you compare two Day Masters, ask which one feeds the other, and say it plainly: the first person's phase generates the second's, or is generated by it.
The controlling cycle
In the controlling cycle each phase restrains another: Wood parts Earth, Earth dams Water, Water puts out Fire, Fire melts Metal, and Metal cuts Wood. Control is not simply bad. In the tradition it gives shape and limits, the way a riverbank guides a river.
Between two people, a controlling link is read as pressure or challenge. The controlling side may be read as setting the pace, the controlled side as feeling held back or, in good conditions, usefully steadied. When two Day Masters share the same phase, the tradition reads them as peers, sometimes as friends, sometimes as rivals for the same ground.
Notice that the two systems ask similar questions with different tools. Both look for support, tension and sameness. Neither, on its own, says whether two people will be happy.
Key terms
- Element
- In Western astrology, one of four groups of signs: fire, earth, air and water.
- Wuxing (five phases)
- The Chinese system of Wood, Fire, Earth, Metal and Water, understood as phases of change.
- Day Master
- The heavenly stem of the day pillar in a BaZi chart, read as the self.
- Generating cycle
- The order in which each phase feeds the next: Wood, Fire, Earth, Metal, Water, and back to Wood.
- Controlling cycle
- The order in which each phase restrains another: Wood controls Earth, Earth controls Water, Water controls Fire, Fire controls Metal, Metal controls Wood.
Worked example
Maya and Jun: same Metal, different water and fire
The BaZi engine gives Maya the day pillar Geng Yin and Jun the day pillar Geng Xu. Both Day Masters are Geng, Yang Metal. In the five-phase reading their Day Masters share the same phase, so neither generates nor controls the other. The tradition calls a same-phase, same-polarity stem a Friend: someone who stands shoulder to shoulder, alike in temperament, possibly competing for the same space.
Their year stems tell a different story. Maya's year stem is Ren (Yang Water) and Jun's is Bing (Yang Fire). In the controlling cycle Water puts out Fire, and the pair Bing and Ren is one of the classical stem clashes. Astrologers would read this as a tension in the wider family or social background each brings, not in the core self.
On the Western side, Maya's Sun is in Pisces and Jun's Sun is in Scorpio. Both are water signs, so their Suns share an element. Maya's Moon, however, is in Leo, a fire sign, while Jun's Moon is in Scorpio, a water sign: a fire and water meeting. One pair of placements suggests ease, another suggests a need for translation. That mixed picture is normal.
History and traditionTwo element systems
The four Western elements come from Greek philosophy. Empedocles described four roots of all things in the fifth century BCE, and Hellenistic astrologers assigned the signs to them in groups of three, which are called triplicities.
The Chinese five phases developed separately. The generating and controlling cycles were systematised by thinkers of the late Warring States period and the Han dynasty, and the theory spread through medicine, calendars, music and statecraft as well as divination.
Try it: Follow the cycle
For each pair of phases, choose how the first meets the second: it generates it, it controls it, or they are the same phase.
Round 1 of 5
Check your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Think about it
Think of a close relationship in your life. Where does one of you tend to give and the other receive, and does that flow ever reverse?
